Carl Mathias Autograph

Current items with a signature of Carl Mathias

These are the most current items with a signature of Carl Mathias that were listed on eBay and on other online stores - click here for more items.

Picture	Item Title	Price	Store
	1960-1961 INDIANS & WASHINGTON SENATORS PITCHER CARL MATHIAS SIGNED INDEX CARD	$3.50
	CARL MATHIAS 1960 TOPPS AUTOGRAPHED SIGNED CARD ROOKIE	$17.95
	Carl Mathias 1960 Topps signed autographed card Cleveland Indians	$8.99

Mathias signed with Cleveland in 1955 after graduating from Oley Valley High School. The Indians recalled him from Triple-A in the midseason of 1960, and used him in seven games, all in relief, with Mathias posting an 0–1 won–lost record, with no saves, through September 26. Then, in December, he was selected by the newly created expansion edition of the Washington Senators with the tenth overall pick in the 1960 Major League Baseball expansion draft. Mathias appeared in four games for the 1961 Senators in midyear after being called up from Triple-A, starting in three of them.

His first start, on June 18, against the Boston Red Sox at Fenway Park, was especially memorable. He pitched into the ninth inning, and left the game with Washington ahead 12–7 and two outs, although Mathias had left the bases loaded. His relief pitcher, Dave Sisler, proceeded to issue a pair of bases on balls to score two Boston runs, then surrendered a walk-off grand slam home run to Jim Pagliaroni, giving the Bosox a 13–12 win. Mathias did not get a decision, but lost the opportunity to register his first MLB win. Mathias was treated rudely by the Chicago White Sox in his next start June 24 and took the loss, the second of his career. He made two more appearances before returning to the minor leagues for the remainder of his pro career. He retired in 1964 after ten seasons. Read even more about Carl Mathias at Wikipedia

Traded items with a signature of Carl Mathias

In total, we tracked 35 items since 01/01/2008. The chart below shows the trade volume over time.

The most expensive item with a signature of Carl Mathias (2009 TOPPS HERITAGE RED AUTOGRAPH CARL MATHIAS #33/60 WASHINGTON SENATORS) was sold in December 2022 for $20.50 while the cheapest item (Carl Mathias signed 3x5 Indians Senators) found a new owner for $0.99 in September 2013. The month with the most items sold (3) was May 2011 with an average selling price of $7.99 for an autographed item of Carl Mathias. Sold items reached their highest average selling price in December 2022 with $20.50 and the month that saw the lowest prices with $1.25 was July 2010. In average, an autographed item from Carl Mathias is worth $4.99.

Most recently, these items with a signature of Carl Mathias were sold on eBay - click here for more items.

Picture	Item Title	Price	Store
	1960 TOPPS -CARL MATHIAS-CLEVELAND INDIANS AUTOGRAPHED VINTAGE ROOKIE CARD	$2.49
	1960 Topps Carl Mathias #139 - RC - Indians - Signed Autograph Auto	$2.15
	1960 Topps Carl Mathias #139 - RC - Indians - Signed Autograph Auto	$2.24
	1960 Topps Carl Mathias #139 Signed Auto Cleveland Indians	$5.99
	1960 Topps Carl Mathias SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED # 139 Indians	$4.99
	1960 TOPPS ROOKIE STAR CARL MATHIAS SIGNED CARD #139 CLEVELAND INDIANS	$19.99
	2009 Topps Heritage Blue Ink Autograph #ROA-CM CARL MATHIAS	$10.00
	2009 TOPPS HERITAGE RED AUTOGRAPH CARL MATHIAS #33/60 WASHINGTON SENATORS	$20.50
	Carl Mathias #139 Signed 1960 Topps MLB Baseball Card Signature Autograph	$4.75
	Carl Mathias signed 3x5	$2.19