Carl Mays Autograph

Carl Mays was a professional baseball pitcher during the early 1900s. Born on November 12, 1891, in Atterson, Alabama, Mays began playing baseball at a young age. He had extraordinary talents and was able to pitch with both his left and right arms. Mays began his major league career in 1915 with the Boston Red Sox. He quickly gained a reputation as a hard-throwing pitcher with pinpoint accuracy. More about Carl Mays

Affiliate disclosure: When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Mays played for several teams throughout his career, including the Cincinnati Reds, New York Yankees, and the Boston Red Sox. He is regarded as one of the most successful pitchers in baseball history. He set a major league record by winning 27 games in his first full season with the Red Sox. Mays also led the American League in wins during the 1921 season, with 27. However, Mays is best known for the pitch that killed Cleveland Indians shortstop Ray Chapman in 1920. While pitching for the New York Yankees, Mays threw a pitch that hit Chapman in the head, killing him. This incident was one of the darkest moments in baseball history and had a lasting impact on Mays’ career.

Despite the tragic incident, Carl Mays continued to play in the major leagues for another nine years before retiring in 1929. He ended his career with a total of 207 wins, 126 losses, and a career ERA of 2.92. After retiring from baseball, Mays became a successful businessman and even authored a book about his baseball experiences. Despite the controversy surrounding him, Mays remains a legendary baseball pitcher whose skills and abilities will always be remembered. Read even more about Carl Mays at Wikipedia

Traded items with a signature of Carl Mays

In total, we tracked 41 items since 01/01/2008. The chart below shows the trade volume over time.

The most expensive item with a signature of Carl Mays (Carl Mays Autographed Signed Baseball RARE Authentic JSA LOA X69254) was sold in July 2013 for $945.00 while the cheapest item (1910s Red Sox Star Carl Mays Signed Christmas Card) found a new owner for $33.67 in October 2008. The month with the most items sold (2) was January 2012 with an average selling price of $153.53 for an autographed item of Carl Mays. Sold items reached their highest average selling price in July 2013 with $945.00 and the month that saw the lowest prices with $38.50 was December 2016. In average, an autographed item from Carl Mays is worth $86.00.

Most recently, these items with a signature of Carl Mays were sold on eBay - click here for more items.

Picture Item Title Price Store
thumbnail1920 YANKEES: Carl Mays, SIGNED 3x5, D.1971!$79.99logo
thumbnailCARL MAYS 1916 & 1918 RED SOX CHAMP SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED 3X5 INDEX CARD *318664$64.99logo
thumbnailCARL MAYS AUTOGRAPH SIGNED 3X5 YANKEES, RED SOX & REDS 1912-32 DIED-1971$150.00logo
thumbnailCARL MAYS AUTOGRAPH SIGNED ALBUM PAGE PSA YANKS RED SOX & REDS 1912-32 DIED-1971$82.00logo
thumbnailCARL MAYS AUTOGRAPH SIGNED GPC YANKEES, RED SOX & REDS 1912-32 DIED-1971$150.00logo
thumbnailCARL MAYS AUTOGRAPH SIGNED INDEX CARD JSA/COA SIGNED LOW BID AWESOME SIGNATURE$59.99logo
thumbnailCarl Mays Autographed 3X5 Index Card Beckett BAS Encapsulated “Killer” Pitcher!$149.00logo
thumbnailCARL MAYS AUTOGRAPHED SIGNED 3X5 $40.00logo
thumbnailCARL MAYS AUTOGRAPHED SIGNED 3X5 YANKEES REDS GIANTS DIED-1971$150.00logo
thumbnailCARL MAYS PSA/DNA CERTIFIED 3X5 INDEX CARD SIGNED AUTHENTIC AUTOGRAPH$151.80logo
thumbnailCarl Mays Signed 3x5 Index Card AUTO Autograph SGC DECEASED 1971$88.77logo
thumbnailCarl Mays Signed CUT AUTO Autograph PSA/DNA AUTHENTIC$83.99logo
thumbnailCARL MAYS Signed Index Card..Deceased in 1971..PSA/DNA Red Sox..New York Yankees$79.00logo
thumbnailCarl Mays signed, matted 3x5 index card - 1915 Red Sox Debut - Deceased 1971$38.50logo
thumbnailScarce CARL MAYS signed index card - Killed Ray Chapman future HOFer$84.55logo