Jim Mutscheller Autograph

Jim Mutscheller was born in 1930 and grew up in Beaver Falls, Pennsylvania. As a high school student, he excelled in both football and basketball, ultimately earning a scholarship to play football at the University of Notre Dame. He was a three-year letterman for the Fighting Irish, playing both end and linebacker positions. In 1951, he was drafted by the Baltimore Colts in the third round. More about Jim Mutscheller

Affiliate disclosure: When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Current items with a signature of Jim Mutscheller

These are the most current items with a signature of Jim Mutscheller that were listed on eBay and on other online stores - click here for more items.

Picture Item Title Price Store
thumbnail1957 Topps Autographed Jim Mutscheller Football Card Colts (d.2015)$20.00logo
thumbnail1959 Topps JIM MUTSCHELLER Autograph #89 Baltimore Colts JSA COA AUTO HOF$29.99logo
thumbnail1959 TOPPS JIM MUTSCHELLER AUTOGRAPHED COLTS VINTAGE CARD -d.2015$3.99logo
thumbnailJIM MUTSCHELLER 1956 TOPPS SIGNED AUTOGRAPHED CARD #72 COLTS$24.95logo
thumbnailJIM MUTSCHELLER 1958 TOPPS SIGNED AUTO CARD #14 COLTS$19.95logo
thumbnailJim Mutscheller Autographed Signed Photo Baltimore Colts JSA & PSA/DNA COA$70.00logo
thumbnailSigned 8x10 JIM MUTSCHELLER Baltimore Colts Autographed photo w/ COA$19.99logo
Mutscheller spent his entire ten-year professional football career with the Colts, making a name for himself as a reliable and versatile tight end. He was a member of the Colts’ famed “Million-Dollar Backfield,” which also included quarterback Johnny Unitas and running backs Lenny Moore and Alan Ameche. Mutscheller was a key contributor to the Colts’ successes in the 1950s, helping the team win two NFL championships in 1958 and 1959. He retired from football in 1961 at the age of 31 and remained in Baltimore, working as a sales representative for a steel company.

Throughout his career, Mutscheller was known for his toughness and durability. He earned the nickname “Big Jim” thanks to his 6’2” frame and 225-pound build. He was a physical player who was willing to do whatever it took to help his team win. Mutscheller was inducted into the Baltimore Ravens’ Ring of Honor in 2001, and his legacy as one of the greatest tight ends in Colts history continues to be celebrated to this day. Read even more about Jim Mutscheller at Wikipedia

Traded items with a signature of Jim Mutscheller

In total, we tracked 201 items since 01/01/2008. The chart below shows the trade volume over time.

The most expensive item with a signature of Jim Mutscheller (Jim Mutscheller 1958-1959 World Champs Baltimore Colts Signed mini Helmet) was sold in December 2014 for $74.99 while the cheapest item (AUTOGRAPHED SIGNED CARD JIM MUTSCHELLER NOTRE DAME FIGHTING IRISH NM C08233) found a new owner for $0.20 in December 2015. The month with the most items sold (8) was July 2008 with an average selling price of $2.75 for an autographed item of Jim Mutscheller. Sold items reached their highest average selling price in December 2014 with $62.49 and the month that saw the lowest prices with $0.99 was April 2008. In average, an autographed item from Jim Mutscheller is worth $5.00.

Most recently, these items with a signature of Jim Mutscheller were sold on eBay - click here for more items.

Picture Item Title Price Store
thumbnail1958 Topps #14 Jim Mutscheller Baltimore Colts Signed Auto *F6256$7.00logo
thumbnail1958 Topps #14 Jim Mutscheller Baltimore Colts Signed Auto *F6257$7.00logo
thumbnail1958 Topps Jim Mutscheller #14 Authentic Autographed Card Baltimore Colts$4.99logo
thumbnail1959 Topps Football IP Autograph Auto #89 Jim Mutscheller$2.25logo
thumbnailBaltimore Colts Jim Mutscheller Signed Photo 8x10 Auto Fan Club Pres Collection $18.50logo
thumbnailJim Mutscheller 1956 Topps Football Player Autograph #72 Vintage$0.99logo
thumbnailJim Mutscheller 1958 Topps Hand Signed$3.25logo
thumbnailJIM MUTSCHELLER 1958 Topps Signed Autographed Football card Baltimore Colts COA$25.00logo
thumbnailJim Mutscheller Signed 1961 Topps #5 Baltimore Colts AUTO PSA PSA/DNA Authentic$9.09logo
thumbnailTK Legacy NOTRE DAME Fighting Irish Jim Mutscheller Autograph FI 53$4.99logo