Lance McIlhenny Autographs
Lance McIlhenny is a former American college football player who was a quarterback for Southern Methodist University. He led the SMU Mustangs to two Southwest Conference championships.
McIlhenny is considered to be one of the greatest option quarterbacks in NCAA Division I-A history. As a freshman, he did not begin the 1980 season as the starter at quarterback, but was promoted during the seventh game against the University of Texas. Future NFL running backs Eric Dickerson and Craig James, combined with blue chip running back Charles Waggoner, were nicknamed the "Pony Express" for their running attack; with McIlhenny leading the offense.
In 1982, he led the Southwest Conference in passing efficiency with a 133 rating. Slocum told Sherrington, McIlhenny “understood option football. ... He had two great running backs at SMU, but he’s the one who made it all go”.
Read more about Lance McIlhenny on Wikipedia
Affiliate disclosure: When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Traded items with a signature of Lance McIlhenny
The most expensive item with a signature of Lance McIlhenny (Lance McIlhenny Autographed 8x10 Photo SMU Mustangs TRISTAR) was sold in May 2026 for $145.00 while the cheapest item (Lance McIlhenny Autographed SMU Mustangs Mini Helmet- JSA Authenticated) found a new owner for $16.50 in October 2016. The month with the most items sold (3) was October 2014 with an average selling price of $20.80 for an autographed item of Lance McIlhenny. Sold items reached their highest average selling price in May 2026 with $145.00 and the month that saw the lowest prices with $16.50 was October 2016. In average, an autographed item from Lance McIlhenny is worth $33.00.
Most recently, these items with a signature of Lance McIlhenny were sold on eBay - click here for more items.
| Picture | Item Title | Price | Store |
 | Eric Dickerson Lance McIlhenny Craig James Signed 'Pony Express' 16x20 Photo PSA | $112.46 |  |
| Eric Dickerson, Craig James And Lance McIlhenny Signed SMU Mini Helmet JSA | $70.00 | |
| ERIC DICKERSON-CRAIG JAMES-LANCE McILHENNY signed PONNY EXPRESS 16x20 Photo--JSA | $80.74 | |
| Lance McIlhenny Autographed 8x10 Mustangs Running Vertical Photo- JSA W Auth | $31.00 | |
 | Lance McIlhenny Autographed 8x10 Photo SMU Mustangs TRISTAR | $145.00 | |
| LANCE MCILHENNY autographed signed SMU blue Jersey Pony Express- McIlhenny holo | $99.00 | |
| Lance McIlhenny Autographed SMU Jersey & Mini Helmet Pair Both JSA COA Methodist | $99.00 | |
| Lance McIlhenny Autographed SMU Mustangs Mini Helmet W/ Go Mustangs- JSA W Auth | $49.00 | |
| Lance McIlhenny Autographed SMU Mustangs Mini Helmet- JSA Authenticated | $16.50 | |
| LANCE MCILHENNY AUTOGRAPHED/SIGNED SMU MUSTANGS PONY EXPRESS 8X10 PHOTO | $29.99 | |
| Lance McIlhenny Pony Express Autographed Blue Jersey- JSA W Auth | $89.10 | |
| Lance McIlhenny Signed *Black 8x10 Mustangs Running Horizontal Photo- JSA W Auth | $35.00 | |
| Lance McIlhenny Signed SMU Mustangs 8x10 Photo (JSA COA) JSA Witnessed | $29.99 | |
| Lance McIlhenny Signed SMU Mustangs Jersey (JSA COA) 3×All-SWC (1981,1982,1983) | $99.95 | |
| Lance McIlhenny SMU Mustangs Autograph Framed 8x10 Photo 'Pony Express' TRISTAR | $125.00 | |
